Negative automatic thoughts often feel like undeniable truths. For example, if someone thinks “Susan doesn’t like me” and it turns out to be accurate, or if they predict “I’ll fail the exam” and indeed fail, it’s easy to accept these thoughts as reality. However, cognitive therapy isn’t just about positive thinking but about realistic thinking. It recognizes that negative events do happen, mistakes are part of life, problems can be put into perspective, and solutions are often within reach.
The Bigger Picture of Negative Thoughts
Even when negative thoughts turn out to be true, it’s helpful to explore their deeper meaning. For instance, if a patient feels hurt by someone’s rejection and is asked, “Why would it bother you if someone didn’t like you?” they might uncover a deeper belief, like, “Because it means I’m worthless.” This negative thought could be linked to a broader, more rigid belief: “If you fail at something, then you are worthless.”
Issues such as depression, anxiety, and relationship conflicts often come from these rigid rules and assumptions. Research shows that beliefs about needing to be perfect or seeking constant approval can make someone more vulnerable to depression, especially when negative experiences trigger these beliefs (Dozois & Beck, 2008; Miranda & Persons, 1988; Haeffel et al., 2005).
Uncovering Core Beliefs
When things are going well, underlying assumptions might stay hidden. To bring these beliefs to light, therapists often look into past distressing experiences. For example, they might ask, “Can you tell me about a time when you felt really bad—what led up to that?” This can help uncover patterns where negative events spark automatic thoughts that reinforce broader, less helpful beliefs.
Alternatively, therapists might ask patients to imagine upsetting situations to reveal their core beliefs. For instance, if a patient thinks about doing poorly on an exam, they might discover thoughts like, “If I don’t do well, it means I didn’t try my best, and that makes me a failure.” By understanding these assumptions, therapists help patients see how specific events can activate more general, negative beliefs.
Exploring Deep-Seated Beliefs and Rules
One technique for uncovering these deep-seated beliefs is the vertical descent procedure. This approach helps reveal the rigid, self-critical rules that can cause emotional distress. For example, if someone thinks, “If I’m alone, I must be unhappy,” it might point to broader assumptions like, “If I’m alone, I’ll always be alone,” or “I must have a partner to be happy.”
These rigid beliefs can increase vulnerability to depression, anxiety, and anger. For instance, if someone loses a job, they might think, “If I got fired, it means I failed.” This belief could lead to thoughts like, “If I’m a failure, I must be worthless,” which can intensify feelings of hopelessness.
Challenging “Should” Statements
Many rigid beliefs come across as moral imperatives or “should” statements, such as, “I should always be perfect” or “I should always succeed.” These demands often lead to self-criticism and guilt. Cognitive therapy aims to challenge these “should” statements by questioning their logic and fairness.
Some helpful questions to explore might include:
“What evidence supports that you should be perfect?”
“Where did this rule come from?”
“Is this rule fair to apply to everyone?”
For example, if a patient thinks, “I should have done better on the exam,” a therapist might ask, “What is the evidence that you should always do your best?” This can reveal insights like, “I’m setting unrealistic expectations for myself,” which can be more helpful than striving for perfection.
Practical Exercises and Homework
Therapists often give homework to help patients identify and track their assumptions and rules. Patients might use forms to record their “should” statements and evaluate their effects. For example, a patient might note, “If I don’t do a perfect job, then I have failed,” and then explore how this belief impacts their anxiety and stress.
Overcoming Common Challenges
Some people worry that challenging “should” statements will make them irresponsible. It’s important to differentiate between rigid “shoulds” and reasonable expectations. While demanding perfection in all areas of life is unrealistic, aiming for personal growth without harsh self-criticism is more achievable.
Therapists can address these concerns by examining whether rigid rules lead to procrastination, avoidance, or lower performance. Techniques like the double-standard approach can help patients reflect on whether they hold others to the same unrealistic standards they set for themselves.
Connecting to Other Therapeutic Techniques
Other techniques that complement this approach include identifying automatic thoughts, vertical descent, and role-playing. These methods help patients understand and reframe their negative beliefs, leading to a more balanced outlook and better emotional well-being.
Conclusion
Dealing with negative thoughts and rigid beliefs can be tough, but it’s a key part of cognitive therapy. By digging into why certain thoughts bother us, figuring out our deeper beliefs, and questioning those “should” statements, we can better understand how these thoughts impact our feelings and actions.
Therapy offers practical tools to help shift these thoughts towards a more balanced view. The aim isn’t to get rid of all negative thoughts or challenges but to find a healthier way to handle them. By learning to recognize and question our own self-critical beliefs, we can develop a more
compassionate and realistic approach to ourselves.
This journey helps us manage our emotions more effectively and build resilience. It’s about finding a way to cope better and live more fully, even when life throws curveballs. With these strategies, we can make strides toward a more positive and satisfying life.
Kommentare